SAO and Irregular at Magic High School: Divisive for Similar Reasons

Sword Art Online and The Irregular at Magic High School have amassed considerable attention and discussion within the anime community. These two series, known for their distinctive flaws, have sparked fervent debates and garnered both passionate fans and ardent critics. Despite their differences in genre, they share several key elements that contribute to their divisiveness.

First and foremost, the main characters in both Sword Art Online and The Irregular at Magic High School have been a subject of intense scrutiny. Starting with Sword Art Online’s protagonist, Kirito, critics argue that he lacks depth, struggle, and charisma. His journey often appears too convenient, as obstacles are overcome effortlessly, and he possesses a seemingly endless supply of skills and abilities. This not only diminishes the sense of challenge in the narrative but also makes Kirito himself an uninteresting character to follow. The lack of character development and the absence of genuine struggles have been a prevalent criticism of Sword Art Online.

However, The Irregular at Magic High School’s protagonist, Tatsuya, receives even harsher criticism. Tatsuya is often seen as a cipher, lacking any significant personality or compelling qualities. Similar to Kirito, the plot seems contrived to favor Tatsuya, robbing the story of tension and making his character even more monotonous. Audiences have pointed out that other series, such as Mashle, manage to play with similar character concepts in a much more engaging and effective manner. Furthermore, both Kirito and Tatsuya receive unwarranted praise from their friends and supporting characters, while their close sibling relationships border on incestuous and uncomfortable, adding another problematic layer to the series.

Another common criticism is the omission of crucial details from the original source material in the anime adaptations of both series. The Irregular at Magic High School, in particular, suffers from a lack of thorough explanation of its complex and scientific magic system, which is better explored in the original novels. Similarly, Sword Art Online fails to adequately develop side characters, mechanics of the game world, and even the protagonist Kirito himself. This can be attributed, in part, to the challenge of translating inner thoughts and narrative devices from the novels to the screen. However, this omission of key elements exacerbates the weaknesses of the storytelling and further undermines the overall quality of the series.

Interestingly, even among those who enjoy Sword Art Online and The Irregular at Magic High School, there is a consensus that the original light novels offer a superior experience. The novels provide more room for character insight and world-building, addressing some of the glaring issues present in the anime adaptations. Despite this acknowledgment, both series remain divisive, and their status as “guilty pleasures” prevails, with many viewers appreciating them despite their flaws.

In summary, Sword Art Online and The Irregular at Magic High School have garnered significant attention and divided opinions. Criticisms regarding weak main characters, lack of challenge, problematic romantic relationships, and the omission of crucial details from the original source material have fueled the ongoing debates. These factors, along with their respective genres, have contributed to the remarkable popularity and simultaneous dislike for both series. Ultimately, Sword Art Online and The Irregular at Magic High School serve as intriguing anomalies, capturing immense heights of popularity while simultaneously enduring substantial criticism.

We bring out some of the most well-known Sword Art Online collection, all of which are available at reasonable costs. Visit our link now if you are interested in the Sword Art Online collection

Lisbeth, Silica, Agil, Heathcliff, Yuuki